Pikmin 4: Nintendo Switch 2 Edition + Dandori Academy is getting review bombed. Its user score on Metacritic has dropped to around 2 out of 10, while critics give it an 83. That kind of split is rare for a Nintendo game. Fans are mostly upset about what they get for the $9.99 upgrade: reused maps, longer load times and still no 60fps.
Updated November 17, 2026. User scores move fast during a review bomb, so the number may be different when you check.
The short version
| Metacritic user score | About 1.8 to 2.3, depending on when outlets checked |
| Metascore (critics) | 83, "generally favorable" |
| Upgrade price | $9.99 for Switch 1 owners; $69.99 for the full Switch 2 Edition |
| Released | November 12, 2026 |
| Nintendo's response | None so far |
What happened
When Nintendo announced the Switch 2 Edition, it sounded like a nice little bonus. We covered it back then in Pikmin 4 Switch 2 Edition: November 12, Dandori Academy and a free demo: 4K visuals, a new Dandori Academy challenge mode and voice commands for Oatchi, for $9.99 if you already own the game.
Five days after launch, players don't seem happy. Nintendo Life reported the Metacritic user score at 2.3, "generally unfavourable." TheGamer saw it at 1.8. Other snapshots landed around 1.9 to 2.1. Meanwhile the critics' Metascore sits at 83. The original Pikmin 4 still holds a user score of around 8.9, so this isn't people hating Pikmin. It's about the upgrade.
We may earn a commission from links on this page.
If you've never played it and just want the game, the Pikmin 4 Switch 2 Edition includes everything, base game and Dandori Academy, in one box.
What fans are angry about
Going through the user reviews and what Nintendo Life, Kotaku and others found, it comes down to a few things:
- Reused content. One reviewer wrote that "half of the maps so far are taken directly from the base game." For a mode that's the main selling point, that stings.
- Longer load times. This one surprised people. YouTuber Press A! reported exit loads of over 30 seconds, versus about 6 seconds on the original Switch. Nintendo Life measured shorter times, about 6 seconds into a cave and 14 to 15 seconds out, but still longer than the old version.
- Still 30fps. No 60fps option on the new, more powerful console. And no mouse controls, which some fans expected with the Switch 2 Joy-Con.
- Value. One user called it "essentially worthless." For a paid upgrade, a lot of people expected more.
To be fair, not everyone agrees. Some fans say a 2 out of 10 is way over the top for a game critics scored 83, and reviewers liked the Dandori Academy challenges themselves. Nintendo Life gave it 7 out of 10.
Should you buy it?
Here's how I'd look at it:
- You already own Pikmin 4 on Switch 1: try the free demo first. If the load times bug you there, they'll bug you in the full upgrade too. If you love Dandori challenges, $9.99 is still not much.
- You've never played Pikmin 4: the base game is great, user scores and all. The Switch 2 Edition gets you everything in one go.
- You only care about performance: wait and see if Nintendo patches the load times. Nintendo Life says it'll keep an eye on that too.
One small tip from players: moving the game from a microSD card to the system's internal storage seems to shorten the load times a bit. If you're running low on space, a fast microSD Express card is what the Switch 2 needs anyway.
Like this kind of news? Get the WIZY weekly: one email every Sunday, no spam.
What to watch
- A patch for load times. That's the most fixable complaint.
- Whether Nintendo says anything. It usually stays quiet on things like this.
- How the user score settles once the first wave of angry reviews passes.
FAQ
Why is Pikmin 4 Switch 2 Edition being review bombed?
Fans say the $9.99 upgrade reuses maps from the base game, has longer load times than the Switch 1 version and still runs at 30fps.
What is Pikmin 4 Switch 2 Edition's Metacritic score?
Critics give it 83. The user score has been around 1.8 to 2.3 since launch.
How much is the Pikmin 4 Switch 2 upgrade?
$9.99 in the US for Switch 1 owners. The full Switch 2 Edition is $69.99.
Sources
- Nintendo Life: Disgruntled fans are review bombing Pikmin 4 on Switch 2 nintendolife.com
- Metacritic: Pikmin 4 Nintendo Switch 2 Edition + Dandori Academy metacritic.com
- TheGamer: Pikmin 4's Switch 2 Edition has a user score of just 1.8 on Metacritic thegamer.com
- Kotaku: Fans are furious with Pikmin 4's Nintendo Switch 2 upgrade kotaku.com



